Set Starstruck

Got this for our game night and we were hooked immediately. The storyline around Jake’s accident is dark but so gripping, and the band’s lingering drama makes every decision feel heavy. We finished two rounds before anyone even checked their phone.

I was nervous this would just be a cash-grab nostalgia trip, but the writing actually makes the band’s early-2000s dynamic feel real. The way the rehearsal accident scene is built up had me holding my breath, and the box set’s extra cards add nice depth to the mystery.

The mystery around Jake's death kept me guessing way past my bedtime, and the interactive clues on the cards are cleverly woven into the story. Even after finishing it, I keep thinking about that final twist.