Class of '98: Mystery Killer-bokssett

Took this to game night and we were all hooked trying to pin down which former friend did it. The suspect list based on the reunion drama kept us arguing for hours, and the small-town Chestnut Falls setting really pulls you in.

The murder-mystery setup is so well written that even my non-gamey friends stayed locked in for the full night. I loved how the suspect list tied back to the reunion theme—it made the whole deduction feel personal.

We had two game nights in a row and couldn't put the box down until we'd interrogated everyone. The suspect cards are so detailed that we completely forgot Charlie's death was fictional.